Tuesday 31 July 2012

Advantages and disadvantages of structured and unstructured play:

Advantages of structured play:
‘Free play and structured play’ (n.d., p.1), commented that advantages could include "cooperative play, sportsmanship, teamwork, strategy and following directions". Morris (2005, p.1), extended on this stating "structured play offers several benefits including: Introducing your child to new ideas and opportunities, enhancing their development and learning abilities, supporting healthy brain development, increasing physical and social skills, providing experience in cooperation, self-discipline and perseverance, developing a positive self-image and building team skills".

Disadvantages of structured play:
Disadvantages can be less time/opportunity for unstructured play (thus preventing the benefits of unstructured play) and causing increased stress. Titus (n.d., p.2) noted that "over scheduling structured play often leads to a child developing stress and anxiety, as well as depression on occasion, according to the APP" (American Academy of Pediatrics). Titus continued to comment that "children with busy structured play schedules may fall behind at school, complain of headaches or stomach aches and feel tired frequently...in addition; families who feel children must be involved in many activities often feel the stress and exhaustion of keeping up with the structured schedule" (n.d., p.2).

Advantages of unstructured play:
According to ‘free play and structured play’ (n.d., p.1) it noted self-regulation, conflict negotiation, problem solving, social-emotional growth, persistence, resilience and collaboration as possible advantages. Titus (n.d., p.2) named the "benefits of unstructured play such as creativity, imagination, decision-making and the development of overall emotional, cognitive and physical strength". Tassoni (2007, p.390) comments that "children tend to concentrate and persevere for long periods when they are ‘in control’ of their learning. Their levels of motivation are higher because they have chosen something that appeals to them".

Disadvantages of unstructured play:
Although there wasn’t much information on the disadvantages of unstructured play, this type of play is about exploration and with exploration comes risk taking. Exposure to more risk and risk taking can expose a child to the result of positive and negatives consequences. Generally if the risk results in a negative consequence then the child will lack the confidence to take the risk again, whilst the parent would limit the child from having the same opportunity out of safety. It could also be noted that if a child is exposed to too much unstructured play that it can be hard for them to adjust to activities that require more structure or following of direction.
 

7 comments:

  1. no entiendo porque mis maestros me ponen a buscar las ventajas y desventajas de un drama

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. lo siento, pero solo hablo un poco español. No este es un artículo sobre un drama. Es un artículo sobre las ventajas y desventajas de actividades y juegos. 'Jugar' es 'to play' en Inglés. Espero que te he ayudado (: Kia ora from New Zealand

      Delete
  2. reference list would have been very helpful

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello from Greece, I am a postgraduate student at the European University of Cyprus and I am doing an assignment on differences between free and structured play. I am looking for recent (after 2010) bibliography,that is articles.Can anyone help me on that?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Best Live Blackjack Games - JamBase
    You'll 여수 출장마사지 be 경기도 출장안마 seeing many options for blackjack, slot machines, and table 인천광역 출장안마 games with this 제주도 출장샵 software by 평택 출장샵 Blackjack Studio. We have all the tools you need to

    ReplyDelete